Monitor Return Period Checklist: What to Test Before Your Window Closes
A systematic testing protocol to catch defects before your return period expires.
Recommended Products
Based on our testing, here are some top picks:
LG 32GN650-B Ultragear Gaming Monitor -
ASUS ROG Swift OLED 27" Gaming Monitor -
$799.00
Samsung Odyssey G7 Gaming Monitor -
Dell UltraSharp U2723QE 4K Monitor -
$612.99
As an Amazon Associate, we earn from qualifying purchases.
Quick Decision Summary
Most retailers offer 15-30 day return windows, but monitor defects often appear gradually or only under specific conditions. This checklist organizes critical tests by priority, ensuring you catch dead pixels, backlight bleed, uniformity issues, and other defects while you can still return the display. Complete Day 1 tests immediately, Week 1 tests within your first week, and ongoing monitoring throughout your return period.
Why Systematic Testing Matters
Many monitor defects aren't immediately obvious. Dead pixels may only appear on certain colors. Backlight bleed becomes visible only in dark environments. Uniformity issues might not bother you until you notice them during specific tasks. Once your return window closes, you're limited to manufacturer warranty claims - which often have stricter defect thresholds than retail return policies.
Retailers like Amazon, Best Buy, and Costco typically accept returns for any reason within their window. Manufacturers often require multiple dead pixels or significant defects before approving warranty claims. Testing thoroughly during your return period gives you maximum flexibility to address any issues.
Day 1 Tests: Immediate Priority
Complete these tests within hours of unboxing. They catch obvious defects that warrant immediate return without further evaluation.
Physical Inspection
Before powering on, examine the panel for scratches, cracks, or damage. Check the bezel for dents or gaps. Inspect the stand for stability and smooth adjustment. Document any physical issues with photos before proceeding.
Dead Pixel Test
Run a dead pixel test displaying solid red, green, blue, white, and black screens. Examine the entire panel surface at normal viewing distance. Dead pixels appear as dots that don't match the displayed color. Even a single dead pixel in your central viewing area may justify return, as manufacturer warranties often require multiple defects.
Obvious Backlight Problems
Display a black screen in a dark room. Look for bright spots, light bleed from edges, or flashlighting in corners. Some backlight bleed is normal on LCD panels, but excessive bleeding that distracts during dark content indicates a defective unit. Use our backlight bleed test for systematic evaluation.
Week 1 Tests: Comprehensive Evaluation
These tests require more time or specific conditions. Complete them within your first week to allow time for return processing if needed.
Uniformity Testing
Display gray screens at various brightness levels (20%, 50%, 80%). Look for darker or brighter patches across the panel. Clouding, dirty screen effect, and uneven backlighting become apparent during this test. Poor uniformity impacts productivity work and immersion in games.
Color Accuracy Verification
If color accuracy matters for your work, test sRGB coverage and color temperature. Professional users should verify Delta E values match specifications. Visible color tints or shifts across the panel indicate calibration or hardware issues.
Response Time and Motion
Test with fast-moving content in games or video. Look for ghosting, smearing, or inverse ghosting (overshoot). Compare motion clarity across different overdrive settings. Poor response time manifests as trails behind moving objects.
Refresh Rate Verification
Confirm your monitor actually runs at its advertised refresh rate. Use our refresh rate test to verify. Some monitors require specific cable types or settings to achieve maximum refresh rates.
Ongoing Monitoring Throughout Return Period
Some issues only appear after extended use or under specific conditions. Monitor for these throughout your return window.
Coil Whine
Listen for high-pitched buzzing or whining from the monitor, especially at certain brightness levels or refresh rates. Coil whine may worsen over time. Test in a quiet room with content that triggers variable power draw.
Heat-Related Issues
After extended use (2+ hours), retest for uniformity and backlight bleed. Some panels develop worse issues when warm. Thermal expansion can reveal hidden defects not visible when cold.
Intermittent Problems
Watch for flickering, signal drops, or random shutdowns. These intermittent issues can be difficult to reproduce but indicate hardware problems. Document occurrences with video if possible for return justification.
How to Decide if This is Right for You
- Return if: You find dead pixels in viewing area, excessive backlight bleed that bothers you, uniformity issues affecting your use, or any defect that detracts from your experience - retail return policies are more lenient than warranty claims.
- Keep if: Minor imperfections don't affect your actual usage, the panel passes all critical tests, and you're satisfied with real-world performance in your specific use cases.
- What to compare: Consider whether issues are within normal variance for the panel type. IPS has glow, VA has slower response, all LCDs have some backlight bleed. Compare against realistic expectations, not theoretical perfection.
Tradeoffs and Limitations
Panel lottery reality: Monitor quality varies unit-to-unit. Returning for minor issues doesn't guarantee a better replacement. Know the difference between defects worth returning versus normal panel variance you might get again.
Testing environment matters: Backlight bleed looks worse at maximum brightness in complete darkness - conditions most people rarely use. Test under your actual usage conditions before deciding an issue warrants return.
Warranty vs return: Manufacturer warranties typically cover defects for 1-3 years but have stricter acceptance criteria. Use your return period for borderline issues that might not qualify for warranty service later.
Documentation importance: Photograph or video any defects. Retailers may request evidence, and documentation helps if issues worsen after the return period ends and you need warranty service.
Common Mistakes to Avoid
Testing at unrealistic brightness: Cranking brightness to maximum makes every panel look worse. Test at your normal brightness setting to evaluate real-world impact.
Waiting until the last day: Returns require processing time. Submit returns at least 3-5 days before your window closes to avoid complications.
Not documenting defects: Memory fades and defects can be hard to reproduce on demand. Photograph issues when you first notice them.
Ignoring burn-in risk for OLED: If you purchased an OLED monitor, vary your content during the initial period. Don't leave static images displayed for extended periods during your return window testing.
Forgetting original packaging: Keep all original packaging, accessories, and documentation until your return period expires. Many retailers require original packaging for returns.
Recommended Testing Tools
Use these tools to systematically evaluate your monitor:
- Dead Pixel Test - Solid color screens for pixel inspection
- Backlight Bleed Test - Dark room evaluation tool
- Uniformity Test - Gray screen uniformity checker
- Should I Return Decision Tool - Interactive return decision helper
Frequently Asked Questions
How many dead pixels justify a return?
For retail returns, even one dead pixel in your central viewing area justifies return if it bothers you. Manufacturer warranties typically require 3-5 dead pixels before accepting claims. Use your return period for any dead pixel concerns.
Is some backlight bleed normal?
Yes, all LCD panels have some backlight bleed. The question is whether it bothers you during actual use. If you only notice it during test screens at maximum brightness, it's likely within normal range. If it distracts during movies or games, consider returning.
Should I test at maximum brightness?
Test at your normal usage brightness. Maximum brightness exaggerates defects you may never notice in practice. However, if you'll use the monitor for HDR content requiring high brightness, test under those conditions too.
What if I find issues after my return period?
You'll need to use the manufacturer warranty, which typically has stricter acceptance criteria. Document all issues and contact the manufacturer's support. Credit card purchase protection may also provide additional coverage.
How long should I burn in a new monitor before testing?
Most modern monitors don't require burn-in time. Test immediately for obvious defects, then retest after a few days of normal use. Some backlight bleed may improve slightly as the panel settles, but significant defects won't self-correct.
Can I return a monitor just because I don't like it?
Most major retailers allow returns for any reason within their window, though some charge restocking fees. Check your specific retailer's policy. This flexibility is why testing during the return period is so valuable.
What's the difference between IPS glow and backlight bleed?
IPS glow is a silver/yellow shine that shifts with viewing angle - it's inherent to IPS technology and not a defect. Backlight bleed appears as bright spots or edge lighting that doesn't change with viewing angle. Learn more in our IPS glow guide.
Should I keep original packaging during the return period?
Absolutely. Most retailers require original packaging for returns. Keep all boxes, foam inserts, accessories, and documentation until your return period expires. Store them somewhere accessible in case you need to repack the monitor.