Why Buy a Used Air Fryer?
Air fryers have revolutionized home cooking, offering healthier fried foods with less oil. Premium models from Ninja, Philips, and Cosori can cost $150-300 new, while quality used units sell for significantly less on the secondhand market.
Recommended Products
Based on our testing, here are some top picks:
Instant Pot Duo 7-in-1 -
$79.99
As an Amazon Associate, we earn from qualifying purchases.
Many air fryers enter the used market lightly used. Some buyers find they don't use them as often as expected, while others upgrade to larger capacity models. It's common to find well-maintained units with minimal wear selling at 40-60% off retail prices.
However, air fryers experience significant heat stress and heavy use. Damaged heating elements, worn non-stick coatings, and faulty controls can affect both performance and safety. This guide ensures you can thoroughly evaluate any used air fryer before purchase.
Hygiene Note: Air fryers are food contact appliances. Thoroughly clean any used unit before first use, and consider replacing the basket if non-stick coating shows significant wear.
Visual Inspection
A thorough visual inspection reveals damage, wear patterns, and overall care. Take time to examine every component of the air fryer.
Exterior Inspection
- Check housing for cracks, dents, or warping from heat
- Look for discoloration or burn marks on plastic
- Inspect ventilation areas for blockage or damage
- Verify all feet/pads are present and level
- Check cord for damage, fraying, or burn marks
Interior Inspection
- Look inside chamber for grease buildup or residue
- Inspect heating element for visible damage
- Check for rust or corrosion inside cooking chamber
- Verify interior coating is intact (if coated)
Cleanliness Assessment
- Heavy grease buildup indicates poor maintenance
- Baked-on food is difficult to fully remove
- Smoke smell may be permanent from overheating
- Clean units typically indicate careful ownership
Basket & Tray Testing
The basket is the most-used component and shows wear fastest. Damaged baskets affect cooking performance and food safety.
Non-Stick Coating Inspection
- Check for scratches, peeling, or flaking coating
- Look for bare metal showing through coating
- Run finger over surface - should be smooth
- Damaged coating can release into food
- Replacement baskets cost $20-50
Basket Mechanism
- Basket should slide in and out smoothly
- Handle release button functions properly
- Basket sits securely when inserted
- No wobbling or misalignment
- Divider inserts (if included) fit correctly
Multi-Layer/Rack Models
- All racks and trays are included
- Racks fit properly in designated slots
- No warping from heat exposure
- Rotisserie spit (if equipped) is straight
Non-Stick Warning: Scratched or peeling non-stick coating should be replaced. Metal utensils cause damage - baskets with multiple scratches indicate improper use.
Heating Element Testing
The heating element is the core of the air fryer. Proper function is essential for cooking performance and safety.
Visual Heating Element Check
- Look at element for damage, discoloration, or breaks
- Check for excessive grease or food buildup on element
- No visible corrosion or pitting
- Element should be evenly positioned
Heating Performance Test
Request to power on and test heating:
- Set to maximum temperature and run for 5 minutes
- Element should glow evenly (if visible)
- Interior should heat up noticeably
- No unusual smells (burning plastic, electrical)
- No smoke (some initial smoke on new units is normal)
Temperature Accuracy
- If possible, verify with infrared thermometer
- Temperature should reach set point within 5 minutes
- Should maintain relatively consistent temperature
- Significant variance indicates calibration issues
Safety Alert: Never operate an air fryer with damaged heating elements. This creates fire risk and is not repairable for most consumer models.
Controls & Display Testing
Air fryer controls vary from simple dials to advanced touchscreens. All controls should function reliably.
Digital Display Models
- All display segments illuminate properly
- No flickering or dead pixels/segments
- Touchscreen responds across entire surface
- Display brightness is adequate
- All preset buttons function correctly
Dial/Knob Controls
- Temperature dial turns smoothly through full range
- Timer dial advances and counts down properly
- Dial indicators are clearly readable
- No loose or wobbly knobs
Function Testing
- Test all cooking presets (fry, roast, bake, reheat)
- Timer starts, counts down, and beeps at completion
- Temperature adjusts in correct increments
- Start/pause functions work
- Unit shuts off when basket is removed (safety feature)
Smart/WiFi Features
- App connectivity works if advertised
- Can connect to your WiFi network
- Remote control functions properly
- Recipes and presets load correctly
Fan Testing
The fan is what makes an air fryer different from a conventional oven. It circulates hot air for even, crispy cooking.
Fan Operation Test
- Fan should start when unit is powered on
- Listen for smooth, consistent fan noise
- No grinding, clicking, or rattling sounds
- Air should flow strongly from vents
- Fan speed may vary during cooking (normal)
Signs of Fan Issues
- Weak airflow indicates motor wear or blockage
- Intermittent fan operation is a failure sign
- Excessive noise suggests bearing problems
- No fan = non-functional air fryer
Ventilation Check
- All vents are clear and unobstructed
- Exhaust vent expels hot air during operation
- No blockage from grease buildup
- Filters (if equipped) are clean and in place
Safety Features
Air fryers include important safety features that must function properly. Never use a unit with compromised safety systems.
Auto-Shutoff Testing
- Unit should pause when basket is removed
- Heating stops immediately with open drawer
- Timer completion triggers automatic shutoff
- Some models have overheat protection
Electrical Safety
- Power cord is undamaged with no exposed wires
- Plug prongs are straight and not burned
- No burning smell during operation
- Exterior doesn't get dangerously hot
- Unit sits stably on counter
Cool-Touch Exterior
- Handle should remain cool during operation
- Exterior housing stays safe to touch
- Only designated areas should be hot
Brand-Specific Guide
Different brands have different features, quality levels, and known issues:
Ninja Air Fryers
Known for: Large capacity, multi-function (Foodi line), good build quality
- Check all cooking functions work (air fry, roast, dehydrate, reheat)
- Verify basket release mechanism isn't loose
- Crisper plate should be included and undamaged
- DualZone models: test both baskets independently
Philips Airfryer
Known for: Original brand, premium build, compact designs
- QuickClean basket should release easily
- Fat removal technology catch should be in place
- Starfish design bottom ensures proper airflow
- Premium models have digital displays worth testing
Cosori Air Fryers
Known for: Good value, smart features, modern design
- Test WiFi/app connectivity for smart models
- Verify touchscreen responsiveness
- Square baskets maximize cooking space
- Shake reminder function should work
Instant Vortex
Known for: From Instant Pot makers, good interface, reliable
- Test one-touch programs
- ClearCook window (if equipped) should be clean
- EvenCrisp technology produces consistent results
- Rotisserie models: verify spit and accessories
Quick Testing Checklist
Use this interactive checklist during your air fryer inspection:
Used Air Fryer Pricing Guide
Reference these price ranges when evaluating used air fryer deals:
| Air Fryer Model | Retail Price | Fair Used Price | Notes |
|---|---|---|---|
| Ninja Air Fryer Max XL | $160 | $80-110 | 5.5 qt, popular size |
| Ninja Foodi DualZone | $200 | $100-140 | Two independent baskets |
| Philips Essential XL | $180 | $90-130 | Premium build quality |
| Philips Premium XXL | $300 | $150-200 | Largest capacity |
| Cosori Pro LE | $120 | $60-85 | Great entry level |
| Cosori Smart WiFi | $140 | $70-100 | App control |
| Instant Vortex Plus | $120 | $60-85 | 6-in-1 functions |
| Breville Smart Oven Air | $400 | $200-280 | Toaster oven combo |
Value Adjustments
- Add 10-15%: Extra baskets, accessories, original box
- Add 5-10%: Light use, excellent condition, recent purchase
- Subtract 15-25%: Scratched basket, cosmetic damage, missing parts
- Subtract 40-60%: Damaged coating, heating issues, worn controls
Red Flags: When to Walk Away
These warning signs indicate serious issues that typically aren't worth the risk:
Peeling Non-Stick Coating
Damaged coating can flake into food. Replacement baskets often cost 30-50% of a new unit.
Burning Smell
Electrical burning smell indicates wiring or heating element damage. Fire hazard - do not purchase.
Damaged Heating Element
Visible breaks, heavy corrosion, or uneven heating pattern. Not field repairable on most models.
Fan Not Working
Without fan circulation, it's just a small oven. Fan motor replacement is usually uneconomical.
Warped/Melted Plastic
Indicates overheating events that may have damaged internal components.
Safety Features Disabled
If auto-shutoff or basket detection doesn't work, the unit is unsafe to use.
Final Expert Tips
- ✓ Run a test cycle - Heat the unit empty for 5-10 minutes to check all functions.
- ✓ Check basket fit carefully - Bent or damaged baskets won't cook evenly.
- ✓ Consider size needs - 4-6 qt works for 1-2 people, 6-8 qt for families.
- ✓ Plan to deep clean - Even clean-looking units need sanitizing before use.
- ✓ Budget for accessories - Silicone liners and parchment rounds extend basket life.
- ✓ Check for recalls - Search model number on CPSC.gov for any safety recalls.
Ready to Air Fry?
Use this guide to find an amazing deal on an air fryer and start cooking healthier today.
Browse Air Fryers on Amazon