How to Test a Used Elliptical Trainer Before Buying

Why Test a Used Elliptical Trainer?

Elliptical trainers offer one of the most effective low-impact cardiovascular workouts available, making them popular choices for home gyms. The used market is flooded with ellipticals from gym closures, corporate fitness centers, and homes where the equipment became expensive clothes hangers. However, these machines are mechanically complex, and hidden problems can turn a bargain into an expensive repair project.

Recommended Products

Based on our testing, here are some top picks:

Apple Watch Series 9 -

$237.25

View on Amazon

Fitbit Inspire 3 -

$93.12

View on Amazon

As an Amazon Associate, we earn from qualifying purchases.

Unlike simpler exercise equipment, ellipticals combine multiple moving systems: drive mechanisms, resistance systems, consoles, and articulating pedal assemblies. Each component can fail independently, and repair costs often exceed the machine's used value. A squeaky or clunky elliptical will quickly become unused, defeating the purpose of your investment.

Quality ellipticals from brands like Precor, Life Fitness, and NordicTrack can provide decades of reliable service when properly maintained. This guide teaches you to identify well-maintained machines and avoid units with developing problems, ensuring your used elliptical purchase provides years of effective workouts.

Drive System Evaluation

The drive system is the mechanical heart of an elliptical, translating your motion into resistance. Drive type significantly affects feel, reliability, and maintenance requirements.

Drive Types Explained

Ellipticals use three main drive configurations: front-drive, rear-drive, and center-drive. Front-drive units are most common, with the flywheel at the front, creating a slightly forward-leaning motion. Rear-drive machines often provide a more natural stride, while center-drive designs offer the most compact footprint. Each has advantages, but drive type mainly affects workout feel rather than reliability.

Flywheel Inspection

The flywheel provides momentum and smoothness to your stride. Heavier flywheels (15-30 pounds in quality machines) deliver smoother motion. Check the flywheel for wobble by observing it spin. Any visible wobble indicates bearing problems or damage. The flywheel should spin freely and come to a gradual, smooth stop.

Belt and Drive Condition

Most ellipticals use belt drives connecting the cranks to the flywheel. Listen for squeaking or grinding during operation. Remove the cover if possible to inspect belt condition - look for cracks, glazing, or excessive wear. A worn belt may slip under heavy resistance, causing jerky motion or inconsistent resistance response.

Resistance System Testing

The resistance system determines workout intensity and is one of the most common failure points in used ellipticals. Understanding and testing this system is crucial for evaluating any machine.

Magnetic vs. Electromagnetic Resistance

Budget ellipticals use manual magnetic resistance with a physical adjustment mechanism. Quality machines use electromagnetic resistance (eddy current) controlled by the console. Electromagnetic systems are generally more reliable long-term but require functioning electronics. Manual systems can fail mechanically but are simpler to repair.

Resistance Range Test

Cycle through all resistance levels while using the machine. Each level should produce noticeably more resistance than the previous. Pay attention to the lowest and highest settings - the full range should be usable. If low settings feel too hard or high settings aren't challenging enough, the resistance system may be compromised.

Resistance Response Time

When changing resistance levels, the change should occur within 1-2 seconds on electromagnetic systems. Significant delays indicate potential motor or control board issues. Manual systems should adjust smoothly without sticking or jumping.

Consistency Check

Set a mid-range resistance level and use the machine at steady pace for 2-3 minutes. Resistance should remain constant throughout. Any fluctuation without input indicates control problems or mechanical issues that will worsen over time.

Console & Electronics Testing

Modern ellipticals feature increasingly sophisticated consoles with touchscreens, workout programs, and connectivity features. These electronics can be expensive to repair or impossible to replace on older models.

Display Function Check

Power on the console and verify all display segments or pixels work correctly. Check for dead pixels, dim areas, or flickering on LCD screens. On touchscreen models, test touch response across the entire screen - unresponsive areas indicate failing touch panels. All text and numbers should be clearly readable.

Metrics Accuracy

Start a workout and verify basic metrics respond correctly. Speed should increase as you move faster. Stride count should increment with each stride. Compare heart rate readings from grip sensors to your own manual count or a known-good fitness tracker. Distance and calorie calculations are based on other metrics, so accurate underlying data matters.

Program Testing

Select several different workout programs and verify they start and run properly. Program-controlled resistance changes should execute correctly. On machines with incline adjustment, verify incline programs change the incline as intended. Note any error messages or frozen states.

Connectivity Features

If the machine has Bluetooth, WiFi, or app connectivity, test these features. Connect your phone if possible. Many older connected machines have outdated apps or discontinued services, reducing their connected functionality. This shouldn't be a dealbreaker but affects value.

Structural Integrity Assessment

Ellipticals must support dynamic loads significantly exceeding user weight. Structural integrity directly affects safety, and compromised frames cannot be economically repaired.

Frame Inspection

Carefully examine all frame welds for cracks, especially near stress points at pivot locations. Look for rust or corrosion, particularly at floor contact points and anywhere sweat may have accumulated. Check for bent or twisted frame sections by sighting along straight sections.

Stability Test

Stand on the pedals at rest and shift your weight side to side and front to back. Quality ellipticals should feel rock-solid with minimal movement. Excessive rocking indicates worn leveling feet, loose frame bolts, or structural problems. Check and adjust leveling feet if possible to rule out simple fixes.

Hardware Check

Inspect all visible bolts, screws, and fasteners for tightness. Look for missing hardware or stripped threads. Pay particular attention to pedal attachment points and handlebar mounting hardware. User-serviceable bolts should be checked and tightened regularly, so loose hardware may indicate neglected maintenance.

Maximum User Weight

Check the manufacturer's maximum user weight rating. Commercial-grade machines typically support 300-400 pounds, while budget home models may rate for only 250 pounds. If you're near the limit, the machine will experience accelerated wear. Consider ratings carefully for long-term reliability.

Ergonomics & Stride Testing

Stride length and ergonomic design affect comfort during extended workouts. An elliptical that doesn't fit your body will become unused regardless of mechanical condition.

Stride Length Evaluation

Stride length is the distance your feet travel in one complete stride. Shorter users (under 5'4") may prefer 16-18 inch strides, while taller users (over 6') need 20-22 inches or more. Use the machine at moderate intensity for several minutes. If your stride feels cramped or overextended, the machine doesn't fit you. Some models offer adjustable stride length.

Pedal Position Check

Your feet should remain flat on the pedals throughout the stride cycle. Excessive toe lifting or heel dropping indicates poor pedal angle or incorrect machine design for your biomechanics. Some ellipticals have adjustable pedal angle - test different settings if available.

Handlebar Comfort

Both stationary and moving handlebars should be comfortable to grip. Check handlebar height relative to your natural arm position. Moving handlebars should track smoothly with the pedals without requiring arm strength to move. Stationary handlebars with heart rate sensors should position sensors where your palms naturally rest.

Incline Function

If the elliptical features powered incline, test the full range of motion. The incline motor should operate smoothly without grinding. Watch for uneven incline or hesitation at certain positions. Manual incline adjustment should lock securely at each setting. Incline affects both workout intensity and ergonomic feel.

Moving Parts Assessment

Ellipticals contain numerous bearings, joints, and articulating components. These wear items significantly affect the machine's feel and longevity.

Pedal Bearing Test

The pedals connect to the machine through bearings that experience constant load. Lift each pedal and check for play (looseness) in all directions. A small amount of play is normal; excessive wobble indicates worn bearings. Rotate the pedal and feel for grinding or rough spots in the bearing.

Arm Linkage Inspection

The moving arm handles connect to the pedal system through pivot points. Check each pivot for excessive play or looseness. These joints should feel solid with no clicking or popping. Worn arm linkages cause an unsettling lack of precision in the motion.

Crank Arm Assessment

The crank arms connect the pedals to the drive system. Grasp each crank and check for any wobble where it meets the drive mechanism. Listen for clicking sounds at the crank-to-pedal connection during use. Crank arms can sometimes be tightened, but worn crank interfaces require major repairs.

Noise Identification

Run the machine while listening carefully. Identify where any sounds originate. Clicking sounds often indicate loose components or worn bearings. Squeaking may be solved with lubrication but could indicate deeper issues. Grinding almost always means significant bearing or bushing wear.

Extended Workout Test

The true test of any elliptical is an actual workout session. Problems often appear only after the machine warms up and components expand, or when used at sustained intensity.

Warm-Up Phase (5 minutes)

Start at low resistance and moderate pace. Listen for any sounds that develop as the machine warms up. Some clicking that wasn't present at cold start may appear. Note the smoothness of motion and any hesitation or irregularity. This phase allows lubricants to warm and components to settle.

Intensity Test (5-10 minutes)

Increase resistance to moderate-high levels and maintain intensity. Quality ellipticals handle sustained heavy use without issues. Listen for changes in sound or feel. The machine should maintain smooth, consistent motion without heating issues. Motor or resistance system problems often appear under sustained load.

Interval Simulation

Rapidly change resistance levels multiple times, simulating interval training. The resistance changes should occur promptly and smoothly. Any stuttering, delays, or erratic behavior indicates control system problems. This tests the responsiveness of the entire resistance system under demanding conditions.

Cool-Down Observation

Reduce intensity and observe the machine as it cools. Listen for any new sounds that appear during cool-down. Check for unusual odors that might indicate overheating components. The transition back to rest should be uneventful.

Elliptical Trainer Brand Guide

Brand reputation and parts availability significantly affect long-term ownership experience. Here's what to expect from major elliptical manufacturers.

Used Elliptical Trainer Pricing Guide

Elliptical values vary dramatically based on brand, condition, and age. Commercial-grade machines hold value better than consumer models.

Final Testing Checklist

Complete this checklist during your evaluation. Check off items as you verify them. Unchecked items indicate areas needing attention.