How to Test a Used Gaming Monitor Before Buying

Why Test a Used Gaming Monitor?

Gaming monitors represent a significant investment, with high-end models from ASUS, Samsung, and LG costing $500-1500 or more. The used market offers substantial savings on premium displays with features like 240Hz refresh rates, 1ms response times, and OLED panels. However, monitors can develop issues that aren't immediately obvious, from subtle dead pixels to degraded backlights.

Panel technology dramatically affects the gaming experience. IPS panels offer superior colors and viewing angles, VA panels provide deep blacks and contrast, while OLED delivers the best of both with perfect blacks. Each technology has specific failure modes and issues to check. A 144Hz monitor that can't actually maintain 144Hz is worthless for competitive gaming.

This guide covers every aspect of used gaming monitor evaluation, from pixel-perfect dead pixel testing to verifying actual refresh rate capabilities. Whether you're looking at a budget 1080p 144Hz display or a premium 4K 240Hz OLED, these tests will help you identify problems before purchase.

Panel Type Verification

Different panel types have distinct characteristics. Verify the seller's claims match reality - some sellers misrepresent panel types to inflate value.

IPS Panel Identification

IPS (In-Plane Switching) panels maintain color accuracy at wide viewing angles. View the screen from extreme angles - colors should remain consistent with minimal shift. IPS panels may show "IPS glow" in dark corners when viewing dark content off-angle. This is normal for IPS but excessive glow indicates quality issues.

VA Panel Characteristics

VA (Vertical Alignment) panels offer superior contrast ratios and deeper blacks than IPS. Display a black image - VA blacks should appear much darker than IPS. VA panels have slower response times and may show smearing in fast motion. Check for "VA smear" by rapidly scrolling bright text on a dark background.

OLED Verification

OLED panels have per-pixel lighting, creating perfect blacks and infinite contrast. In a dark room, display a black image - true OLED will appear completely off with no backlight bleed. Check for burn-in by displaying a gray image and looking for ghost images of UI elements or logos. OLED burn-in is permanent.

Dead Pixel Testing

Dead, stuck, or hot pixels are permanent defects that cannot be fixed. Even a few in the wrong location can be distracting during gaming. Thorough pixel testing is essential.

Full-Screen Color Test

Display full-screen solid colors: pure red, green, blue, white, and black. Examine every area of the screen carefully for pixels that don't match the surrounding color. Dead pixels appear black on all colors; stuck pixels stay one color regardless of what's displayed; hot pixels appear white on dark backgrounds.

Systematic Scanning

Divide the screen into sections and examine each methodically. Pay extra attention to the center and areas where you'll focus during gaming. Edge pixels are less critical but clusters of defects anywhere are concerning. Use a magnifying glass for higher resolution displays.

Brightness Uniformity

Display a mid-gray image and check for uniformity. Backlight bleed typically appears as brighter areas along edges, especially corners. Clouding appears as uneven brightness patches across the panel. Some backlight bleed is normal on edge-lit displays; excessive amounts are problematic.

OLED Burn-In Check

For OLED displays, show a solid gray (50%) image in a dark room and look for any retained images. Common burn-in includes taskbars, game HUDs, or channel logos. Even slight burn-in will worsen over time. Any visible burn-in significantly reduces value.

Refresh Rate Verification

Gaming monitors are valued for their high refresh rates. Verify the monitor actually achieves its advertised refresh rate and that adaptive sync works correctly.

Native Refresh Rate Test

Connect to a computer and check display settings for available refresh rates. A 144Hz monitor should show 144Hz as an option. Some monitors require specific ports - DisplayPort often supports higher refresh rates than HDMI. Verify you can select and apply the advertised maximum refresh rate.

UFO Test

Visit testufo.com and run the frame rate test. This displays moving objects that clearly show the actual refresh rate. At 144Hz, the UFO should appear noticeably smoother than at 60Hz. Frame skipping or inconsistent motion indicates refresh rate problems or connection issues.

Adaptive Sync Testing

If the monitor supports G-Sync or FreeSync, verify it functions. Enable the feature in monitor OSD and graphics driver. Run a game or benchmark with variable frame rates and check for screen tearing. Properly functioning adaptive sync eliminates tearing without adding input lag.

Overclocking Stability

Some monitors can be overclocked beyond advertised specs. If the seller claims overclocked refresh rates, verify stability. Run the higher refresh rate for several minutes while watching for frame skipping, artifacts, or blackouts. Unstable overclocks can damage the monitor.

Response Time & Motion Clarity

Response time determines how quickly pixels change color, affecting motion clarity. Advertised response times are often misleading - real-world testing reveals actual performance.

Motion Blur Test

Use testufo.com's ghosting test or scroll rapidly on a webpage. Fast-moving objects should remain sharp without trailing "ghosts." Significant ghosting or smearing indicates slow pixel response. VA panels typically show more ghosting than IPS; excessive ghosting on any panel type is problematic.

Overdrive Settings

Most gaming monitors have overdrive settings to improve response times. Test each overdrive level. Too much overdrive causes inverse ghosting (bright trails behind objects). Find the optimal setting that minimizes ghosting without causing overshoot. If no setting looks good, the panel may be defective.

Black-to-Black Transitions

Dark scene transitions are particularly challenging for VA panels. Display dark content with movement (space games, horror games) and watch for smearing. This "black smear" is inherent to VA technology but shouldn't be excessive. Compare to reviews of the same model if possible.

Motion Blur Reduction

Some monitors have backlight strobing for motion blur reduction (ULMB, ELMB, DyAc). Test this feature if present - it should dramatically improve motion clarity. Note that this feature typically can't be used simultaneously with adaptive sync. Verify it functions without flickering or brightness issues.

Color Accuracy & HDR

Color accuracy matters for competitive gaming visibility and immersive experiences. HDR capability adds value but varies dramatically in quality.

Color Gradient Test

Display color gradient images and check for smooth transitions without visible banding. 8-bit panels may show banding in gradients; 10-bit panels should appear smoother. Excessive banding indicates panel limitations or incorrect color depth settings.

sRGB Coverage

Most gaming monitors target sRGB color space. Colors should appear natural without oversaturation. If the monitor has multiple color modes, test each. Factory calibration quality varies - some monitors are well-calibrated out of the box while others need adjustment.

HDR Evaluation

Enable HDR and display HDR content. True HDR requires high peak brightness (600+ nits minimum, 1000+ for good HDR) and local dimming. Budget "HDR" monitors often have poor implementation. Check that HDR mode actually improves highlights and doesn't just wash out the image.

Brightness Levels

Test minimum and maximum brightness. Minimum should be comfortable for dark room gaming without being too dim. Maximum brightness affects HDR impact and bright room visibility. Verify brightness adjusts smoothly without flickering at low levels (PWM concerns).

Inputs & Feature Testing

Verify all inputs work and gaming-specific features function correctly. Failed ports or features reduce the monitor's value.

Port Testing

Test each video input (DisplayPort, HDMI, USB-C) individually. All ports should detect signal and display correctly. Check that high refresh rates work on appropriate ports - older HDMI versions may be limited to 60Hz at high resolutions. USB hub ports should recognize devices.

OSD Functionality

Navigate through the entire On-Screen Display menu. All settings should adjust correctly. Physical buttons or joystick should respond consistently. Settings should save after power cycling. Look for any locked or grayed-out options that should be accessible.

Gaming Features

Test crosshair overlays, FPS counters, black equalizer/shadow boost, and any other gaming features. These should activate and function as advertised. Low input lag modes should noticeably reduce response time. Some features may disable others - verify compatible combinations.

Picture-by-Picture

If PBP or PIP modes are advertised, test them with two sources. Both inputs should display simultaneously. Some monitors have limitations on which ports work together. This feature is valuable for streaming or productivity multitasking.

Physical Condition Assessment

Physical damage affects both aesthetics and functionality. Inspect all external components carefully.

Screen Surface

Examine the screen surface with the display off under bright light. Look for scratches, scuffs, or coating damage. On matte screens, coating damage appears as shiny spots. On glossy screens, scratches are more visible. Minor scratches may only show on specific content.

Bezel & Housing

Check bezels for cracks, chips, or separation from the panel. Inspect the housing for damage that might indicate drops or impacts. Damaged housing can indicate internal damage. Verify all covers and panels are present and properly attached.

Stand & Mount

Test all stand adjustments: height, tilt, swivel, rotation. Movements should be smooth without grinding or excessive looseness. The monitor should hold position without sagging. Check VESA mounting holes if present - stripped threads prevent mounting alternatives.

Power & Cables

Verify the power supply is included and functional. External power bricks should show no damage or excessive heat discoloration. Check if cables are included - original cables ensure compatibility. Inspect cable connections for bent pins or damage.

Gaming Monitor Brand Guide

Brand reputation affects quality, warranty support, and resale value. Here's what to expect from major gaming monitor manufacturers.

ASUS ROG

Premium gaming brand with excellent feature sets. Swift series known for high refresh rates and G-Sync. Good build quality and gaming-specific features. Strong resale value on ROG models.

Key tests: Variable overdrive, ELMB sync, refresh rate verification

$658.93

Compare ASUS ROG monitors on Amazon

Samsung Odyssey

Leading in curved VA and OLED gaming displays. Excellent contrast ratios and innovative designs. Neo G-series offers mini-LED backlighting. Strong in the high-end segment.

Key tests: VA smearing, curve uniformity, HDR performance

Compare Samsung Odyssey monitors on Amazon

LG UltraGear

Excellent IPS and OLED options. Known for fast IPS panels with good color accuracy. Leading OLED gaming monitors. Strong all-around choice for most gamers.

Key tests: OLED burn-in, IPS glow, color accuracy

Compare LG UltraGear monitors on Amazon

BenQ Zowie

Esports-focused with excellent motion clarity. DyAc technology for blur reduction. Popular among competitive FPS players. Less flashy but performance-focused.

Key tests: DyAc function, Black eQualizer, motion clarity

Compare BenQ Zowie monitors on Amazon

Alienware

Dell's gaming brand with premium build quality. Early OLED gaming adopter. Excellent stand designs and aesthetics. Strong warranty support through Dell.

Key tests: OLED burn-in, build quality, all gaming features

$297.36

Compare Alienware monitors on Amazon

MSI

Good value gaming monitors with solid feature sets. Wide range from budget to premium. Curved VA options popular. Good mid-range choice.

Key tests: Panel lottery (QC varies), overdrive settings, build quality

$648.30

Compare MSI gaming monitors on Amazon

Used Gaming Monitor Pricing Guide

Gaming monitor values depend on panel type, resolution, refresh rate, and condition. OLED panels hold value well; older LCD panels depreciate faster.

Final Testing Checklist

Complete this checklist during your evaluation. Pixel defects and panel issues are the most critical items.

Ready to find your used gaming monitor?

Compare Gaming Monitors on Amazon